Ox and Goat Compatibility
牛 · Niú & 羊 · Yáng
Result
Challenging
Two earth signs pulling opposite ways: a stubborn standoff is the main risk, and clear roles help most.
What the classical tables say
- Clash (chong, 冲): A clash joins two branches that sit opposite each other on the twelve-branch circle, and the tables read it as strong pull in opposite directions, with energy that is lively but hard to keep steady.
- Punishment (xing, 刑): A punishment joins branches that rub against each other in the tables, and it is read as a pairing of pressure, stubbornness and testing, where each side can press on the other without meaning to.
Sources: San Ming Tong Hui (三命通会), Ming dynasty, 16th century.
Overview
Ox (chou) and Goat (wei) sit opposite each other on the branch circle, a Clash in the classical tables, so the match is graded Challenging. They also share a Punishment in the old lists, which adds pressure. Both are earth branches, so you value security, but Ox seeks it through discipline and Goat through comfort and feeling. The clash is in the method, not in the aim.
Sources: San Ming Tong Hui (三命通会), Ming dynasty, 16th century (Ox and Goat branches form a Clash (chou-wei), with a Punishment also listed).
Love
In love, Goat is tender, creative and sensitive to mood, while Ox is steady, practical and sparing with words. Goat may feel that Ox is unfeeling; Ox may feel that Goat is demanding or changeable. Both of you want a warm home. When tension rises, Ox goes silent and Goat becomes emotional, which makes each feel worse. A calm, simple word of reassurance can break the pattern.
Sources: San Ming Tong Hui (三命通会), Ming dynasty, 16th century (Ox and Goat branches form a Clash (chou-wei), with a Punishment also listed).
Friendship and work
In friendship or work, Ox is dutiful and organised; Goat is imaginative and prefers a gentler pace. A shared project can succeed when you give each a defined area: Ox for logistics and Goat for design or people. It goes wrong when Ox insists on one method and Goat resists without saying why. Respect for the other's pace is the quiet foundation of any shared work.
Sources: San Ming Tong Hui (三命通会), Ming dynasty, 16th century (Ox and Goat branches form a Clash (chou-wei), with a Punishment also listed).
What to watch
Two earth signs under a clash can become immovable. Ox holds firm on the rule and Goat holds firm on the feeling, and the argument becomes about who is being unreasonable. Take a break before decisions made in anger. Use a neutral third party, such as a calendar or a written list, to settle practical points, and keep emotional talk for a calmer hour.
Sources: San Ming Tong Hui (三命通会), Ming dynasty, 16th century (Ox and Goat branches form a Clash (chou-wei), with a Punishment also listed).
Three habits that help
- Give each person one area where the other will not interfere.
- When voices rise, stop and resume the talk after an hour.
- Use a written list for chores and money so they stay free of blame.
2027 for this pair
No month in 2027 is a good month for both signs.
Months follow the solar terms, not the 1st of each month.